First, I wedged a thick piece of paper between the elevator and the canard and traced out the profile of the elevator. However, this method only provided one data point per side. How about the profile somewhere in between?

My second approach included a carpenter's widget and a small piece of aluminum plate. I placed the aluminum against the bottom side of the elevator (which is flat) and extracted the top profile with the widget. I took 3 sets of profiles per elevator - a total of 6 data points. Together with the 2 ends profiles (above method, totaling 8), they gave me a pretty good picture of my elevator profiles.           

I traced these profiles on top of the plans profile and sent them to Dennis Oelmann for review (Dennis Oelmann built my canard & elevator). After a few phone calls and e-mails, we concluded that the 'lack of concave' is probably caused by excessive micro overfill at the concave location and that the desirable profile can be recovered with a 'bit' of sanding. I offered to take a shot at it first. If I cannot make it right, Dennis offered to make it right.  Regardless...

Starboard (before sanding):

This was how my starboard elevator looked. There was quite a bit of micro fill left at the concave location. Note the two pencil marks I drew along the trailing edge (.3" and 1.5" from the trailing edge respectively)...

That's where I'll concentrate on the sanding.

Just a closer look at the profile. I can feel very slight concave, but not significant.

After I sand off most of the micro overfill (no removal of glass), the concave started to show. However, I was using a piece of sandpaper wrapped around a wood dowel and I was not able to get a real consistent concave profile along the entire length of the elevator. 

Another picture of the starboard profile after my first round of sanding. Note the slight concave profile... I was not satisfied and I think I need a final sanding/shaping with a profile sanding block to make it better.

Port (before sanding):

This was how my port side elevator looked. Again, I drew two straight lines (.3" and 1.5") along the trailing edge respectively. 

That's where I'll concentrate on the sanding.

Port side after the 1st round. Note the slight curvature...

I like this curvature a bit better than the starboard side. I think I had a bit more practice...

Another shot of the port side after the 1st round. Again, it looked OK but I was not satisfied. I think I need a slight final shaping with a fixture as well.

Here's the tools I have used. The top and the left were used in the 1st round...

The one at the bottom right is the wood sanding fixture with the elevator profile I used in the second round (below). I just wrapped a small strip of sand paper only and ran it along the trailing edge of the elevators. It removed the extra micro at the concave location.

Here's my starboard side after the 2nd round with the profile fixture. This fixture helped me to achieve a more pronounced and consistent concave profile along the trailing edge. Not perfect, but pretty close.

Just a closer look at the outboard end. The shape looks much nicer than after the 1st round...

Here's my port side after the 2nd round. Again, consistent along the trailing edge. Not perfect, but pretty close.

Another look at the port side outboard.